Quote:
Originally Posted by lsutiger17
I have a question for you guys that say ASM is a ponzi scam where new money is needed to keep the market going. I do agree with this statement and I have been saying that since I started at ASM back in April of 2005.
Here is my question: "If ASM started using advertising on the site and used that money to either eliminate commissions by using that to fund the div pools and for profit or just used it as a supplemental source for the div pools would ASM still be a Ponzi Scam?"
Thanks for your answers guys.
|
It wouldn't be one because as many have said from the beginning, all ASM needs is an external source of funds. Everybody who had math at school and isn't blinded by a pair of shades will easily see that the current set-up won't work because the commissions force you to always sell higher than you bought (or sell for a loss) and sooner or later, someone will have to end up with shares that are soooo way overpriced that no one will buy them anymore. ASM was smart enough to disguise that as much as they could with bonus money, illogical split rules, forced splits, a guy who claims that some things in the market can't be explained because humans act irrationally, etc.
But no matter how much they disguise it, the underlying model remains a ponzi scheme as long as the traders are responsible for funding their own (!) dividends (which is the major difference to a real market.. funny that Alpi, the business major, fails to see that.. well, actually not that funny since he's working for ASM.. but oh well).
Now, the thing with advertising and external sources of income has been brought up many times. The first time it was suggested, Glock and Chris replied, "We don't like ads. Period." The discussion was over before it started.
A few months ago, Chris all of a sudden threw out a little forum post stating that ASM will look into selling ad space (and worded it as if it was his own idea). However, as everything that could contribute to ASM becoming legitimate, this post quickly vanished in the forum depths and has never been brought up again.
Does that answer your question?
P.S.: Thanks for the insight from a real programmer's point of view, Vince!